The Antonine Plague’s Smallpox Diagnosis Remains Unsettled

A death toll of about 10% is one reconstruction of Rome’s Antonine Plague. Genetic studies and disease models show why its cause remains debated.

The Antonine Plague’s Smallpox Diagnosis Remains Unsettled
Marble portrait of Marcus Aurelius, approximately 161–169 CE. Louvre MR 561, photographed on loan at the Metropolitan Museum of Art. Photograph: Pierre-Selim Huard, CC0.

The Antonine Plague is often described as a smallpox pandemic that killed about a tenth of the Roman Empire’s population. Both parts of that description are historical reconstructions. The epidemic is documented in ancient writing, while its diagnosis and total death toll remain subjects of scholarly debate.

Research published in PLOS ONE in February 2025 tested several possible diseases against accounts of an outbreak in Rome. Its simulations compared smallpox, measles and different forms of plague. The results left the cause unresolved and raised questions about treating reports from different decades as one continuous pandemic.

For the Antonine Plague in Roman history, this debate reaches beyond the name of a disease. Identifying a pathogen changes the assumptions used to estimate how it spread, which people were most vulnerable and how many died. The familiar figure of 10% belongs within that discussion of evidence and interpretation.

An Epidemic Across Imperial Reigns

The outbreak conventionally begins in 165 CE, during the reign of Marcus Aurelius. References to epidemic disease continue through the following decades. Modern histories frequently connect these reports into a pandemic extending into the 180s, although the accounts describe different places and provide uneven information about symptoms.

One important episode concerns the army at Aquileia in northern Italy. Galen recalled severe mortality there during a winter usually identified as 168–169 CE. His testimony places disease within the military world of the emperor’s reign and gives historians a particular location and setting to examine.

Another major report comes from Rome under the emperor Commodus, around 189 CE. Cassius Dio described exceptionally heavy daily deaths in the capital. Connecting that episode to the earlier outbreak creates a long chronology, one that researchers must test against the different diseases proposed as its cause.

Detail of Dumont’s nineteenth-century lithograph portraying Galen with curly hair, a full beard and a draped robe.
Detail of a later portrait of Galen in a lithograph by Aristide Dumont, probably 1810–1819. Wellcome Collection, Public Domain Mark.

Galen’s Rash Became the Key Clue

The writings of Galen of Pergamon supply much of the clinical evidence used in modern diagnoses. Particularly influential is his account of a skin eruption that could ulcerate and leave scars. That description helped establish smallpox as a leading explanation of the Antonine epidemic.

The identification gained ground in scholarship from the nineteenth century and became especially influential in later studies. Smallpox offered historians a disease whose transmission, course and fatality could be investigated through much more recent outbreaks. Those comparisons supplied the starting points for reconstructions of an ancient epidemic.

Other researchers have challenged that approach by examining the history of the virus itself. A disease’s symptoms and severity can change as its pathogen evolves. An ancient description of a scarring rash therefore has to be considered alongside genetic evidence about the forms of variola virus that existed at different times.

Roman bronze scalpel with a broad slotted end, a round opening and a long tapering shaft on a pale background.
Roman bronze scalpel, first–second century CE. The Metropolitan Museum of Art, 74.51.5327; The Cesnola Collection, purchased by subscription, 1874–76. Public domain.

Ten Per Cent Is One Reconstruction

The 2025 study reviews estimates that range widely. An influential 1973 analysis proposed an average death rate of 7–10% across the empire, with higher figures of 13–15% in cities and the army. Another prominent reconstruction put mortality across the empire at roughly 8–10%, with more severe losses in the worst affected places.

Other interpretations have produced substantially lower or higher totals. The differences reflect disagreements over ancient testimony, demographic assumptions and the meaning of economic changes. Surviving references to deaths, wages, rents and population movements require interpretation before they can support an estimate for an empire containing many different local communities.

A population death toll also measures something different from a disease’s case fatality rate. The latter concerns the proportion of infected people who die; an empire-wide mortality estimate concerns the population as a whole. Estimating the second requires assumptions about how many people became infected, where outbreaks occurred and how often disease returned.

Ancient DNA Reopened the Chronology

A 2022 review in the Journal of Roman Archaeology questioned whether smallpox, as understood from recent medical history, existed in the ancient Mediterranean. It drew attention to genetic differences between early medieval variola lineages and those responsible for smallpox in later centuries, and challenged their use as interchangeable historical diagnoses.

A study published in Microbial Genomics in January 2023 reached an older estimate for the virus’s ancestry. Its researchers analysed modern, historic and early medieval genomes and adjusted their dating method for changes in estimated evolutionary rates over different timescales. Their analysis placed the common ancestor of sampled variola genomes around 4,000 years ago.

That revised estimate makes a much earlier history of the virus plausible. It is a calculation of evolutionary ancestry, rather than the recovery of variola DNA from an Antonine victim. The researchers also stressed that several infections can produce similar rashes and that identifying affected ancient societies requires evidence from archaeological specimens.

Modern panoramic view of the Roman Forum, with the Arch of Septimius Severus, standing temple columns and the Palatine Hill.
The Roman Forum photographed in 2019, looking east across its surviving monuments. Photograph: Nicholas Hartmann, CC BY-SA 4.0.

Testing Disease in the City of Rome

The 2025 modelling study approached the problem through the capital’s population. It began with a published archaeological estimate of approximately 923,000 inhabitants and simulated disease between 165 and 189 CE. Some models followed infection among humans alone; plague models also included rats and fleas as possible components of transmission.

The simulations tracked groups of people susceptible to infection, infected or recovered. Some versions added an exposed group to represent the interval before a person became infectious. Parameters drawn from epidemiological literature allowed the researchers to compare how the different candidate diseases might behave within the same demographic framework.

Across the scenarios, a large initial outbreak was followed by much smaller waves. The models failed to reproduce the heavy daily mortality reported for the end of the period. The authors considered several explanations, including a separate later epidemic, seasonal transmission and differences between ancient pathogens and their modern counterparts.

Dio’s Daily Deaths and the Wider Toll

Cassius Dio supplies one of the most striking numerical reports. In his account of Commodus’ reign, the historian wrote:

“Moreover, a pestilence occurred, the greatest of any of which I have knowledge; for two thousand persons often died in Rome in a single day.”

Cassius Dio, Roman History, 73 [72].14.3.

The report describes repeated days of exceptional mortality in one city. In the 2025 study it becomes a particular historical claim against which simulations can be compared. Its relationship to the earlier epidemic, and the extent to which its number can be taken literally, are central to that comparison.

The Antonine outbreak thus remains a documented episode of serious disease whose interpretation draws on several kinds of evidence. Galen’s clinical observations, Dio’s urban death toll and reconstructed viral histories address different parts of the problem. Establishing how those records fit together is essential to explaining the epidemic’s reach and evaluating the population losses attributed to it.

About the Roman Empire Times

See all the latest news for the Roman Empire, ancient Roman historical facts, anecdotes from Roman Times and stories from the Empire at romanempiretimes.com. Contact our newsroom to report an update or send your story, photos and videos. Follow RET on Google News, Flipboard and subscribe here to our daily email.


Follow the Roman Empire Times on social media: